Skip to content
Menu
beitmalkhut.org beitmalkhut.org
  • contact us
  • yizkor—minyan remembrances
  • tzaddik stories
  • seymour fromer z”l
    • mira z. amiras — san francisco
    • harold lindenthal — nyc and hartford
    • fred rosenbaum, brooklyn and berkeley
    • joe hoffman, jerusalem
  • jewish mysticism, magic, and folklore
    • study group topics and schedule
  • recommended readings
    • death and dying
    • selected articles by mira
beitmalkhut.org beitmalkhut.org

daily kaddish: for jrr tolkein

Posted on 2 September 20119 February 2016 by erin

[powerpress]

Mira wrote:

J.R.R. Tolkein died today Sept 2nd, in 1973
http://www.digitalhistory.uh.edu/news/obituaries2.cfm

He’s definitely worth a kaddish! So here’s mine!

To say that his work continues to enchant is not to say really much about him.  Maybe it says more about Peter Jackson and tedious film making that’s worth holding the remote on fast-forward through all the overblown battle gore.  To watch Jackson’s Lord of the Rings (even the extended version) you’d think that Tolkein was primarily a military strategist, rather than a linguist, folklorist and damned beautiful writer.  He constructed languages and mythologies like no one else. Drew his own maps. And dragons. And calligraphy. Jackson, on the other hand, left out every nuance that could not be captured by a sappy smile and boy-hug.  And Goldenberry, a gem in Tolkein’s universe, he left out entirely.  Does anyone read Tolkein anymore? I used to read LOTR and some of his other works every single summer when I wasn’t traveling.  He gave me the feeling of being along inside the adventure. And yah, he had battles, sure.  But it was easy to just turn the page and they’d be gone.   Tolkein deserves a kaddish played by the elves of Middle Earth.  I picture him, like Gandalf, riding through the English countryside, pen and notebook in hand.  Probably the Cotswolds.  Rest in Peace, and thank you for endless adventures and beautiful sentences.

Mira and I made this recording as an asynchronous trio. We each listened to a previously-recorded horn track and recited the text where we felt it belonged, taking turns—listening only to the horn, not to the other voice track.

1 thought on “daily kaddish: for jrr tolkein”

  1. Pingback: daily kaddish: quintet

Comments are closed.

email mira and erin: kaddish@beitmalkhut.org

  • kaddish in two-part harmony (555)
    • essays (160)
    • guest essays (11)
    • podcasts (388)
    • project news (13)
    • tzaddik stories (31)
  • Seymour Fromer z"l (16)
  • the rebbe's queer daughters (11)
  • a kaddish for the math prof who taught me the most important thing i ever learned about music
    by erin
  • Protected: a sample recording
    by erin
  • a kaddish for the forestry buff who also played horn pretty well
    by erin
  • in the beginning…
    by erin
  • kaddish for anke akevit (2015-20)
    by erin
  • a kaddish for too many suicide victims—but it gets better!
    by erin
  • a kaddish for sigrid syltetøy vang, b. 2006, d. 27 February 2018
    by erin
  • guest kaddish: velvet marquesa flicka storm, 11 august 2005–9 april 2015
    by erin
  • the stones I cannot place
    by mira
  • oh amy, how could you — a kaddish for amy smith
    by mira

anthropology backstage cats Charlotte Adams China choreography collaboration dads death death and dying divorce dogs exhaustion grief japan Jewish identity John Manning kabbalah kaddish life cycle Magnes Museum Malkah Middle East moms mourning murder music musicians musicology parenting piano ritual Sephardi Seymour Fromer Space Place suicide supine text the rebbe's queer daughters tzaddik tzaddik stories University of Iowa women writing yahrtzeit

Copyright

© 2010–24 by Mira Z. Amiras and Erin Vang (beitmalkhut.org). All rights reserved worldwide.

thank you—תודה רבה

Permission to use Lev Kogan's "Kaddish," © 1982 by Israel Brass Woodwind Publications
In-kind support: Global Pragmatica LLC®

meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
©2026 beitmalkhut.org | Powered by Superb Themes