Skip to content
Menu
beitmalkhut.org beitmalkhut.org
  • contact us
  • yizkor—minyan remembrances
  • tzaddik stories
  • seymour fromer z”l
    • mira z. amiras — san francisco
    • harold lindenthal — nyc and hartford
    • fred rosenbaum, brooklyn and berkeley
    • joe hoffman, jerusalem
  • jewish mysticism, magic, and folklore
    • study group topics and schedule
  • recommended readings
    • death and dying
    • selected articles by mira
beitmalkhut.org beitmalkhut.org

a kaddish for six people in arizona

Posted on 16 January 201123 March 2011 by erin

[powerpress]

Last Saturday, a guy with a lot more ammunition than mental stability fired 31 rounds into a crowd at a political event outside a supermarket. It isn’t clear to me whether his goal was to commit murder specifically—of Congresswoman Gabrielle Giffords—or to commit mayhem generally.

Among his accomplishments was to stir up a week of shouting by the people who get paid a lot to shout. Better writers than I have written many words on the subject, and I don’t pretend for a moment that I have any insights or an analysis to compete with those that have been so widely published since last Saturday.

So far the writer making the most sense to me is Frank Rich, who points out in today’s column in the New York Times that the two issues that this horrible incident should be raising to headlines are the two things that are least likely to change as a result of this incident: gun control and mental health care. Also I am grateful for President Obama’s speech, which elevated the public conversation, especially when it called critical attention to the conversation.

But I’ve barely heard or read about the part that seems most important to me. The lede has been buried again and again. The details of that man’s delusions are irrelevant. The popular political discourse is almost as horrifying as the frequency with which mass shootings like these seem to fill the news, but that discourse is not directly relevant. I mean no disrespect for Rep. Giffords, nor the others injured; may her recovery and theirs be fuller and swifter than we dare hope. Nor do I mean to dismiss the questions we need to ask about mental illness, mental health care, gun control, and how close to the brink of chaos our society dwells. These issues are serious and important.

But what is indisputably germane is what we have barely heard and read.

Six people were killed, and we don’t even know their names.

Christina Green.

Dorothy Morris.

John Roll.

Phyllis Schneck.

Dorwin Stoddard.

Gabriel Zimmerman.

May their memories be a blessing to those who knew them. May their memories not be wasted by the rest of us thinking that their tragedy is fodder for careless argument.

A Kaddish for the six who died. May they rest in peace.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Categories

  • kaddish in two-part harmony (552)
    • essays (158)
    • guest essays (11)
    • podcasts (388)
    • project news (13)
    • tzaddik stories (31)
  • Seymour Fromer z"l (16)
  • the rebbe's queer daughters (11)

Posts

  • kaddish for anke akevit (2015-20)
  • a kaddish for too many suicide victims—but it gets better!
  • a kaddish for sigrid syltetøy vang, b. 2006, d. 27 February 2018
  • guest kaddish: velvet marquesa flicka storm, 11 august 2005–9 april 2015
  • the stones I cannot place
  • oh amy, how could you — a kaddish for amy smith
  • guest kaddish: Gudrun Fossum Vang (16 June 1905–3 April 1972)
  • occasional kaddish: for Josephine Selvig Anderson (11 April 1915– 22 January 2012)
  • and death is so much closer than it was—a kaddish for rebecca fromer
  • easy come easy go: a kaddish for adrienne cooper
  • nyt remembrances—a kaddish for departed strangers
  • guest kaddish from David Mohr—for Kimba
  • killing you loudly—a kaddish
  • anything, anything but a mystical experience
  • daily kaddish: our project’s yahrtzeit

Contact the authors

email mira and erin: kaddish@beitmalkhut.org

Archives

anthropology backstage cats Charlotte Adams China choreography collaboration dads death death and dying divorce dogs exhaustion grief japan Jewish identity John Manning kabbalah kaddish life cycle Magnes Museum Malkah Middle East moms mourning murder music musicians musicology parenting piano ritual Sephardi Seymour Fromer Space Place suicide supine text the rebbe's queer daughters tzaddik tzaddik stories University of Iowa women writing yahrtzeit

Copyright

© 2010–22 by Mira Z. Amiras and Erin Vang (beitmalkhut.org). All rights reserved worldwide.

thank you—תודה רבה

Permission to use Lev Kogan's "Kaddish," © 1982 by Israel Brass Woodwind Publications
In-kind support: Global Pragmatica LLC®

meta

  • Log in
  • Entries feed
  • Comments feed
  • WordPress.org
©2023 beitmalkhut.org | Powered by Superb Themes